More on That

Wednesday, January 11th, 2012

As I said in my last post, I don’t think the distribution of that and which is adequately explained by the restrictive/nonrestrictive distinction. It’s true that nearly all thats are restrictive (with a few rare exceptions), but it’s not true that all restrictive relative pronouns are thats and that all whiches are nonrestrictive, even when [...]

Posted by Jonathon at 10:33 pm | 13 Comments »

Which Hunting

Friday, December 23rd, 2011

I meant to blog about this several weeks ago, when the topic came up in my corpus linguistics class from Mark Davies, but I didn’t have time then. And I know the that/which distinction has been done to death, but I thought this was an interesting look at the issue that I hadn’t seen before. [...]

Posted by Jonathon at 3:05 pm | 3 Comments »

Whose Pronoun Is That?

Saturday, October 29th, 2011

In my last post I touched on the fact that whose as a relative possessive adjective referring to inanimate objects feels a little strange to some people. In a submission for the topic suggestion contest, Jake asked about the use of that with animate referents (“The woman that was in the car”) and then said, [...]

Posted by Jonathon at 9:42 pm | 7 Comments »

Rules, Regularity, and Relative Pronouns

Wednesday, October 19th, 2011

The other day I was thinking about relative pronouns and how they get so much attention from usage commentators, and I decided I should write a post about them. I was beaten to the punch by Stan Carey, but that’s okay, because I think I’m going to take it in a somewhat different direction. (And [...]

Posted by Jonathon at 4:55 pm | 8 Comments »

Who, That, and the Nature of Bad Rules

Tuesday, August 2nd, 2011

A couple of weeks ago the venerable John E. McIntyre blogged about a familiar prescriptive bugbear, the question of that versus who(m). It all started on the blog of the Society for the Promotion of Good Grammar, where a Professor Jacoby, a college English professor, wrote in to share his justification for the rule, which [...]

Posted by Jonathon at 12:23 am | 10 Comments »